Answer for: Do you think women should be soldiers?

#3 Why Not?  

Click to show full-size image

You know, just out of curiosity

 

Related products from Amazon (See more...)

Why Not Be A Mystic
Why Not Be A Mystic
$16.95 (12/31/1969 05:00 pm ago)

Comments    |   Leave a comment Leave a comment

Avatar Image
      Thumbs down Thumbs up   
Sam Member (Level 5): 3,276 points   2 years ago

The following arguement is strictly from a biological standpoint. My personal opinion is that if women want to be soldiers, more power to them.

The reason it's bad for women to be soldiers is because men are more expendable. Women can have lots children if there are only a couple men. Men can't have lots of children if there are only a couple women.

In classical history, there were often truces that lasted 20-30 years, to allow for a city to reestablish its male population (with the help *cough* of the conquering city, of course).

The Thirty-Year Truce between Athens and Sparta (after the Persian War) is an example. So many men had been killed, they couldn't afford to have their fighting men go off to battle. If they did, their societies would collapse. Someone has to plow the fields, make the bread, and all of that. About 14 years after the Truce was formed, Athens broke it, just long enough for a generation of children to grow up...

This arguement doesn't hold up quite as well anymore, since the number of people on the planet is so much higher and the survival rate of infants is much better.

Reply to this comment  Reply     Link to this comment Link
Avatar Image
      Thumbs down Thumbs up   
Traroth Member (Level 5): 2,829 points   1 year ago

Being a soldier is about killing people, at the end. Are you really curious about that?

Reply to this comment  Reply     Link to this comment Link

Related Answers

Grupies who voted on this answer also voted on:

Answer Details

Total votes: 25

Subscribe

Please login or register to see notification options.

Feedback

(Log in or register to see feedback options)